Can You Put a Paper Plate in a Toaster Oven?

Trying to decide what types of dishes are safe to put in a toaster oven and which can cause a hazard is something that many people can struggle with. From foil-lined trays for baking pizza to the aluminum roasters you use for turkeys, it seems like everyone has a different opinion on which items are okay in these smaller ovens.

One item that often comes up in conversations related to these kitchen appliances is paper plates; can you actually put them in your countertop appliance?

To help answer this question, this post will explore the safety risks associated with such behavior as well as other useful information related to putting paper plates into a toaster oven.

An Overview of Toaster Ovens

Toaster ovens are a type of small appliance that can be used to bake, toast, and warm foods. They come in various sizes and feature either analog or digital controls for regulating the temperature.

Toaster ovens usually have an interior made of stainless steel or porcelain-coated steel, with a door at the front. The heating element is typically situated either at the top or bottom of the unit, with a rack for holding food inside.

What is the Difference between a Toaster Oven and a Conventional Oven?

Toaster ovens and conventional ovens are both used to bake food, but they have some distinct differences.

Toaster Ovens:

  • Smaller in size and capacity than conventional ovens
  • Cook food faster due to the smaller interior space
  • Can be used for a variety of cooking tasks like baking, toasting, and warming foods

Conventional Ovens:

  • Larger in size and capacity than toaster ovens
  • Generally require more time to cook food
  • Can be used for tasks like baking, roasting, and broiling

Can you Put a Paper Plate in a Toaster Oven?

No, it is not safe to put a paper plate in a toaster oven. This type of oven operates at high temperatures and the paper plate can easily catch fire.

Additionally, the heat from the appliance may cause the paper plate to break down and release harmful toxins into the air. It is always best to use dishes made specifically for use in a toaster oven.

Tips for Using Paper Plates in a Toaster Oven.

If you must use a paper plate in your toaster oven, there are some tips you can follow to ensure safety.

  1. Place the plate on a baking sheet before putting it into the oven. This will help protect the paper plate from direct contact with heat and prevent it from catching fire.
  2. Make sure the temperature is set to its lowest setting. This will help reduce the risk of the paper plate catching fire.
  3. Monitor the oven closely while cooking. Keep an eye on the paper plate and remove it as soon as it starts to brown or smoke.
  4. Do not leave a paper plate unattended in your toaster oven, even if you are using a baking sheet to protect it.

Alternatives to Using Paper Plates in a Toaster Oven.

Rather than using paper plates, it is best to invest in bakeware specifically designed for use in a toaster oven. Silicone baking mats and trays are ideal since they can withstand high temperatures without melting or warping. They also help distribute heat evenly throughout the oven chamber so your food cooks more efficiently.

Other Safety Considerations When Using a Toaster Oven.

Aside from not using paper plates, there are some other things to keep in mind when operating a toaster oven.

  • Always make sure the oven is plugged into a grounded outlet and that the wiring is secure.
  • Do not use combustible materials (such as plastic wrap or foil) inside the oven chamber as they can easily catch fire.
  • Do not leave the appliance unattended while it is in use.
  • Clean the toaster oven regularly to remove any debris or food particles that may pose a fire hazard.
  • Never put a paper plate into your conventional oven as this can result in an even greater risk of fire.


It is not safe to put a paper plate in a toaster oven. The high temperatures of this appliance can cause the paper plate to catch fire or release harmful toxins into the air. Instead, opt for dishes specifically designed for use in these types of ovens and follow the other safety tips outlined above. This will help ensure that your food is cooked properly and that you remain safe while using your toaster oven.


2 ratings